Cheesy Garlic Stuffed Baked Potatoes

Table of Contents

Cheesy Garlic Stuffed Baked Potatoes

These cheesy garlic stuffed baked potatoes have crisp russet skins, a creamy garlic filling, and a golden top made with sharp cheddar and mozzarella. The potatoes are baked whole, scooped out, and refilled with buttery mashed potato, sour cream, and cheese. A second trip to the oven heats the filling and gives the cheese time to melt and brown around the edges.

The photo inspired the whole-potato presentation. A shallow opening on top leaves enough skin around the sides to hold the filling, so each potato stands upright on the plate. Serve them with roasted zucchini and bell peppers, a handful of salad greens, or a spoonful of sour cream. They work as a hearty side dish or as the center of a simple lunch with vegetables.

Prep time — 20 minutes
Cook time — 65 to 80 minutes
Total time — 1 hour 25 minutes to 1 hour 40 minutes
Servings — 4, one whole stuffed potato per serving
Cooking method — Oven baking and stovetop sautéing

Ingredients

  • 4 medium russet potatoes, about 8 ounces (225 g) each
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • ½ teaspoon fine sea salt, divided
  • 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 3 garlic cloves, finely minced
  • ½ cup sour cream
  • ¼ cup whole milk, warmed, plus a little more if needed
  • 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar, about 4 ounces (113 g)
  • ½ cup shredded low-moisture mozzarella, about 2 ounces (57 g)
  • ¼ teaspoon ground black pepper
  • 2 tablespoons chopped fresh parsley

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Prepare the potatoes

Preheat the oven to 425°F (220°C). Scrub the potatoes under running water and dry them thoroughly. Pierce each potato several times with a fork. Rub the skins with the olive oil and sprinkle them evenly with ¼ teaspoon of the salt. Set them on a rimmed baking sheet with space between them.

Bake the potatoes uncovered so the skins dry out and crisp. Choose potatoes of similar thickness if you can. A long, narrow potato may finish sooner than a short, wide one of the same weight.

2. Bake until tender

Bake the whole potatoes for 50 to 65 minutes, checking the smallest one first. Slide a thin knife or skewer into its center. It should go in easily, without hitting a firm spot. If the center still feels hard, give the potatoes another 5 to 10 minutes and check again.

Take the baked potatoes out of the oven and leave the oven on. Let them sit for about 5 minutes, until you can steady them with a clean kitchen towel. They’ll still be warm enough to mash easily.

3. Make the garlic butter

While the potatoes bake, melt the butter in a small skillet over medium-low heat. Add the minced garlic and stir for 30 to 60 seconds, until it smells fragrant. Remove the skillet from the heat while the garlic is still pale. Finely minced garlic browns quickly and can taste bitter if it gets too dark.

Toss the cheddar and mozzarella together in a bowl. Set aside ½ cup of the cheese mixture for the topping. The remaining cup goes into the filling.

4. Scoop out the centers

Set each potato on its broadest side so it sits steadily. Cut a thin oval lid from the top and lift it off. Use a spoon to scoop the soft potato flesh into a mixing bowl, leaving about ¼ inch of potato attached to the skin around the sides and bottom. Scrape any soft flesh from the lids into the bowl as well.

Work from the center outward. The ends tend to tear first, so leave a little extra potato there if the skins feel delicate. Return the hollowed shells to the baking sheet.

5. Mix the filling

Add the garlic butter, sour cream, black pepper, and remaining ¼ teaspoon salt to the warm potato flesh. Mash by hand until mostly smooth. Stir in the warm milk a tablespoon at a time. The exact amount you’ll need depends on the potatoes. Stop when the mash is creamy enough to spoon and firm enough to hold a mound.

Fold in the 1 cup of mixed cheese and 1 tablespoon of parsley. Taste the filling before adding more salt, since sharp cheddar can vary in saltiness. A few soft potato pieces are fine. Mash only as much as you need to get the texture you want.

6. Refill and bake again

Divide the filling evenly among the four shells. Spoon some into each end first, then mound the rest over the opening. Gently rough up the tops with the back of a fork so a few peaks stick up. Scatter the reserved ½ cup of cheese over the potatoes.

Return the tray to the oven and bake for 15 minutes, or a few minutes longer if needed, until the filling is hot and the cheese is melted with golden spots. For deeper browning, move the tray under the broiler for the final 1 to 2 minutes and watch it closely.

7. Garnish and serve

Let the potatoes settle for a couple of minutes, then sprinkle them with the remaining parsley. Slide a wide spatula under each potato to lift it onto the plate. Serve while the tops are golden and the cheese is still soft.

Helpful Cooking Tips

  • Pick russets with a broad, stable side. This makes it easier to cut a wide opening and gives you a shell that stands upright when filled.
  • Use a hand masher or a fork. A blender or food processor can make cooked potato flesh sticky. Mash while it’s still warm for an easier, fluffier filling.
  • Add the milk gradually. The filling should sit above the rim without slumping. If it already looks creamy after a couple of tablespoons, save the remaining milk.
  • Shred the cheese from a block if convenient. Freshly shredded cheddar and mozzarella melt evenly. A coarse grater makes it easy to fold some into the filling and scatter the rest over the tops.
  • Keep the shells on the baking tray while you fill them. If one splits, tuck its sides back around the mash and set it against a neighboring potato for support during baking.

Recipe Notes

Sharp cheddar gives the filling its tangy flavor, while low-moisture mozzarella makes the topping stretchy and helps it brown. A white sharp cheddar will give you a paler top with the same tang. Chives can replace parsley if you want a mild onion flavor.

For smaller portions, cut the baked potatoes in half lengthwise and fill all eight halves. They’ll have more exposed surface for the cheese and work well on a buffet. Start checking them after about 12 minutes on the second bake, since shallower portions heat faster.

The roasted zucchini, bell peppers, and sour cream pictured alongside the potatoes are serving ideas. A lemon-dressed green salad adds some acidity to the plate. For a fuller meal, serve the potatoes with grilled chicken, roasted salmon, or a chickpea salad.

Make-Ahead & Reheating

For make-ahead prep, assemble the stuffed potatoes and refrigerate them covered before the second bake. When you’re ready to serve, bake them at 400°F (200°C) until the centers reach 165°F (74°C). Start checking at 25 minutes. The exact time depends on how cold and densely filled the potatoes are. You can also reheat cooked leftovers at 350°F (175°C) until they reach 165°F (74°C) throughout. ask.fsis.usda.gov

Estimated Nutrition Per Serving

One serving is one whole stuffed potato. Estimates include the filling and cheese topping. Optional accompaniments are separate.

  • Calories — 480
  • Protein — 17 g
  • Carbohydrates — 44 g
  • Total fat — 27 g
  • Saturated fat — 14 g
  • Dietary fiber — 3 g

Nutrition Benefits

Russet potatoes provide carbohydrates for energy, plus potassium and some dietary fiber. Eating the skin adds fiber to the serving. The cheddar, mozzarella, and milk contribute protein and calcium. The cheese, butter, and sour cream also account for most of the saturated fat in the dish.

Questions & Answers

Can I use Yukon Gold potatoes?
Yes. Yukon Golds make a creamy filling and have thinner skins than russets. Choose larger ones and leave a slightly thicker layer of potato inside each skin so it can hold the filling.

Can I make these without sour cream?
Yes. Use the same amount of plain Greek yogurt. Stir it into the warm mash, then add only as much milk as needed to reach a spoonable consistency. Full-fat Greek yogurt gives a creamy result with a mild tang.

How can I fix a filling that’s too thick?
Stir in warm milk 1 tablespoon at a time until the filling is easy to scoop. If it’s too soft, let it sit for a few minutes before filling the shells. The mash firms up slightly as it cools.

Why did my potato skins tear?
The sides may have been scooped too thin. Leave a layer of potato attached to the skin and use the edge of the spoon gently around the opening. A small tear can usually be pressed together and supported by the baking tray.

Leave a Comment